The Michigan Wolverines have been slapped with a cheating allegation by the NCAA. They have been accused of stealing signs from their opponents.[1] Michigan allegedly had unnamed individuals attend games of scheduled opponents to evaluate the teams’ signs and steal them.[2] Supposedly, Michigan employed a former military captain to help them decipher and steal opposing teams’ signals.[3] Two of Michigan’s opponents even told Yahoo Sports that they became aware that Michigan knew their play signs.[4]
While sign stealing on its own may not be a breach of NCAA rules, the use of electronic equipment to relay the information to players on the field or to coaches is a violation.[5] The 2023 NCAA rules state that “any attempt to record either through audio or video means, any signals given by an opposing player, coach or other team personnel is prohibited.”[6] Ultimately, teams are allowed to scout opponents via video, but it is illegal to intercept those communications or relay them to your team via electronic equipment.[7]
On September 23rd, the Wolverines destroyed Rutgers 31-7. However, one of the major story lines coming from the game was that during the halftime interview Rutgers head coach, Greg Schiano, said, “[t]here’s some stuff going on out there …. There’s some things going on that aren’t right as well, so we’ll talk about how to handle it.”[8] While the Rutgers media claimed that this was not a shot at the Wolverines, in the college football world it was considered suspicious in light of the cheating allegations.
“A source told ESPN that Michigan has used an ‘elaborate’ scouting system to steal signs from future opponents since 2021.”[9] Michigan head coach, Jim Harbaugh has denied any wrongdoing in past and present cheating allegations.
However, if these allegations are true, this would mean that Michigan was able to survey the opponent’s sideline, notice the intricacies of the operation, and then report to the coaching staff what certain signals meant. The ability to do this would allow the Wolverines to “completely short-circuit an entire play-calling system.”[10] This would give any team an extreme advantage and, assuming equal skill levels between teams, would make a team virtually unbeatable.
The Michigan Wolverines are currently ranked second in the country and are one of the favorites to win the national championship this year. Jim Harbaugh will need to rally his troops and block out the distractions in order to keep this train on the tracks. If found guilty of these cheating allegations, the football team and the University will surely face catastrophic penalties and can kiss their national championship hopes goodbye.
[1] Michigan: Jim Harbaugh cheating allegations of sign-stealing, explained (usatoday.com)
[2] Id.
[3] Michigan’s ‘Sign-Stealing’ Scandal Is a Cautionary Tale for the NFL – Sports Illustrated
[4] Michigan: Jim Harbaugh cheating allegations of sign-stealing, explained (usatoday.com)
[5] Id.
[6] Id.
[7] Id.
[8] Rutgers coach Greg Schiano may have hinted at Michigan sign stealing (nypost.com)
[9] Id.
[10] Id.
Leave a Reply