The NHL fined Brad Marchand $5,000 for unsportsmanlike conduct during the Buffalo Sabres-Florida Panthers game on October 18. The fine follows a brawl that ensued between the Panthers forward and Rasmus Dahlin. What started as a typical fight on the ice between the two players after Dahlin checked Marchand from behind, and some punches were thrown, suddenly turned bizarre. But it is what occurred in the penalty box that prompted Marchand’s fine.
Upon receiving a four-minute penalty (two minutes for roughing, two minutes for interference), Marchand was seen holding Dahlin’s helmet. While in the penalty box, Marchand ripped the straps off Dahlin’s helmet before “chucking it back onto the ice.”[1]
According to the NHL Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA), “any Player who is assessed a minor penalty or misconduct for abuse of official or unsportsmanlike conduct may be subject to a fine.”[2] The maximum fine a player can receive under the CBA is $5,000—the amount Marchand was fined for his conduct during his game against the Sabres. But with an estimated annual salary of $5.25 million[3], a $5,000 fine is likely pocket change for Marchand—and most NHL athletes. Fines from the NHL for unsportsmanlike conduct are meant to be a punishment for the player’s poor conduct and a deterrent for other players from doing the same. However, how effective are these fines if they likely do not have the intended impact? The new NHL CBA is set to begin on September 16, 2026 and will not expire until September 15, 2030.[4] It is unclear whether the new CBA will change its guidelines on the maximum amount of fines permitted. But what is clear is that the NHL needs to implement stiffer fines to ensure players are actually deterred from conduct similar to Marchand’s.
[1] https://www.sportsnet.ca/nhl/article/panthers-brad-marchand-fined-5k-for-unsportsmanlike-conduct-vs-sabres/
[2] https://cdn.sanity.io/files/zkpnl5e1/production/f514e479621435032baf076a5125791a2b99cbaf.pdf
[3] https://www.nhl.com/news/brad-marchand-signs-6-year-contract-with-florida-panthers
[4] https://www.espn.com/nhl/story/_/id/45732725/nhl-nhlpa-cba-new-rules-salary-cap-trades-ebugs-84-games
Leave a Reply