While playing in Munich, Germany, this past Sunday, Aidan Hutchinson faced an unfortunate, season-ending injury. Hutchinson sacked New England Patriots quarterback Drake Maye in the first quarter and, like most defensive ends in the NFL, went on to celebrate his big play. However, as Hutchinson leaped into the air in victory, his right knee buckled, causing him to land awkwardly. Now, Hutchinson faces a torn ACL and possible additional damage in his right knee. This is the second time Hutchinson has faced a season-ending injury in three years, after breaking his left leg in 2024 against the Dallas Cowboys on a sack. Granted, his knee may have already been in a fragile state, and this injury could have happened on the following drive, but there are questions regarding whether Hutchinson should be paid given that his injury happened while carelessly celebrating, rather than playmaking.
According to Paragraph 9 of the NFL Standard Player Contract, if a player is injured “during the performance of his services,” he will continue to receive his yearly salary. While there is no defined term for what constitutes a football-related injury, the fact that Hutchinson was on the field playing for the Detroit Lions strongly indicates that this injury will be fully covered. Not only is Hutchinson entitled to his salary, but he is also entitled to other benefits such as medical care, pension credit, and Injury Protection, which provides payment to players if they sustain a career-ending injury. But when is a team not liable for player injuries?
It may be obvious that a team is not liable for injuries that occur when players are off the clock, but what counts as “off the clock” is less clear than it sounds. In 2021, offensive tackle Ja’Wuan James was fully guaranteed a $10 million salary. However, he sustained a season-ending Achilles injury while working out at a private gym away from the Denver Broncos facility. The NFL distributed a memo to all 32 teams shortly after, clarifying that if a player works out “on his own” in a location other than an NFL facility and becomes injured, the injury is deemed a “non-football injury.” These injuries permit teams to have no contractual obligation to provide a player’s salary for that year. For James, this meant he lost his $10 million, was released by the team, and had to follow the grievance procedure outlined in the CBA.
Hutchinson is lucky his fluke injury occurred during a game, or else he would be at risk of losing out on his recent four-year $180 million contract extension. His injury demonstrates that the liability line is more so drawn by where the injury occurs, not by how careless it was. Even though every player has celebrated in some fashion, players need to ensure they don’t get too carried away, as a season-ending injury can happen during unsuspecting moments.
Sources:
Marlowe Alter, Aidan Hutchinson injury update has Lions DE with torn ACL: Live updates, Detroit Free Press (Nov. 16, 2026).
Around the NFL Staff, Lions’ Aidan Hutchinson out for 2026 season with torn ACL, NFL Network (Nov. 16, 2026).
Nick Shook, NFL clarifies clubs have no contractual obligation if players are injured working out away from team facility, NFL Network (May 5, 2021).
Jeff Legwold, Jamison Hensley and Dan Graziano, Ja’Wuan James files $15 million grievance against Denver Broncos, reaches two-year deal with Baltimore Ravens, sources say, ESPN (June 7, 2021).
NFL, NFLPA, Collective Bargaining Agreement, Appendix A, Paragraph 9.
Lily Busler is a 3L at the University at Buffalo School of Law with a focus on intellectual property and trademark law. In law school, Lily is involved with the Student Bar Association of Erie and Monroe County, Phi Alpha Delta, and the Law & Business Association. She also serves as a Senior Associate Editor for the Buffalo Environmental Law Journal and the Buffalo Human Rights Law Review. Outside of school, Lily is a die-hard Buffalo Bills fan and was a season ticket holder for many years.
Leave a Reply